Home Popular Rush to close toxic land deal revealed

Rush to close toxic land deal revealed


NSW government officials made no attempt to independently verify the value – or to negotiate the price – of a piece of contaminated land in Camellia before paying a developer $53.5m for the site, according to an internal audit report.

The six-hectare site at Camellia, near Parramatta, is going to be used as a maintenance facility for the Parramatta light rail project.

The site, contaminated with asbestos, hexavalent chromium and other harmful chemicals, was bought by a property developer for $38 million in November 2015, just days before the multi-billion-dollar Parramatta light rail project was announced.

Seven months later, the government took over the land and the developer made a $15.5m million profit.

But an independent valuation, which put a price tag of only $15.5m on the site, wasn’t done until after the land was bought.

An internal Transport NSW document, released to the state parliament, reveals there were concerns about the rushed process a full year before Transport Minister Andrew Constance referred the matter to a corruption watchdog following a media investigation.

“It’s a stunning level of incompetence that raises serious questions,” NSW opposition finance spokesman Daniel Mookhey said.

In the November 2019 report, the authors write Transport officials didn’t wait for the project to be fully approved before buying the land “due to the availability of the land on the open market”.

But the first government offer, based on an initial valuation, was rejected and a third party swooped in to buy the property instead.

Within half a year that developer came back to the government with an offer to sell at an inflated price.

That increased asking price was “based on vendor expectations of the development value of the property”, the report states.

“The acquisition was then accelerated by (Transport for NSW); however, management did not obtain a formal independent valuation of the property at that time.”

“The audit did not see … evidence that efforts had been made to engage and negotiate an agreement with the vendor.”.

After the purchase, an independent valuation was sought.

“(Transport) management were unable to provide evidence of further work performed to gain additional assurance of the land valuation,” the report states.

The audit also found there weren’t regular checks for conflicts of interest done during the acquisition process, exposing the agency to “an increased risk of perceived or actual fraud/corruption in the commercial land acquisition process”.

The document is the result of an internal probe into processes around acquiring land for infrastructure projects and was done by the department’s audit and risk division.

The Transport Minister declined to comment because the matter has been referred to the Independent Commission Against Corruption and the NSW Auditor-General.

“Given I have made referrals on this matter to other independent agencies, I can’t comment any further at this stage,” Mr Constance said in a statement.

A Transport NSW spokesman said the audit was undertaken “as part of normal practices” and recommendations had been “absorbed into our restructure program so that the appropriate systems and processes can be developed and implemented”.

“Transport for NSW welcomes the investigation by the Auditor General and the Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) and will give its full assistance in any way it can support this process,” he said.

“Given the matter of the land purchase has been referred to ICAC, it would be inappropriate to comment further.”



Source link

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Must Read

Leading 10 Best Cross Country Moving Firms

If you're planning to move to Chula Panorama, The Golden State, you must recognize that there are many relocating firms that offer long-distance moving...

PETER HITCHENS: USA wants war to drive Russia back to the Stone Age

This is not a war between Ukraine and . It is a war between the USA and Russia, in which both sides are cynically...

nft хасбика

Добрый День, Дорогие Друзья. Сейчас я бы хотел поведать малость про aglet nft. Я думаю Вы искали именно про nft pop it trade?! Значит эта больше актуальная...

Nintendo Switch tops lifetime sales of Wii console

By Sam Nussey TOKYO, Feb 3 (Reuters) - Nintendo Co Ltd sold 18.95 million Switch video game consoles in the nine months to the...

The Fact About karaoke That No One Is Suggesting

kangnam 셔츠룸후기 강남셔츠룸시스템 - An Overview